Disgruntled SID

Tuesday, August 15, 2006

Gruntled Killed the Disgruntled Stars?

Is the D-SID Board dead? Very few posts, even fewer new threads by bloggers in recent months. One would think this would be the time to vent...

Well, the SID field is in good shape if SIDs want a positive place to post. The SID board is booming and the malcontents are slithering into the high grass.

Me thinks we need 'em both--just like the cheques and balances of the legislative, executive and judicial branch.

D-SID RIP?

Tuesday, August 08, 2006

Non-anonymous SID Discussion

There have been quite a few comments made regarding anonymous posting, mostly negative. As much as I think blogging anonymously can be fun, refreshing and even informative, I do see the benefit in having certain discussions among identified individuals.

As Bruce Schneier said in column titled Anonymity Won't Kill the Internet, "The problem isn't anonymity; it's accountability. If someone isn't accountable, then knowing his name doesn't help. If you have someone who is completely anonymous, yet just as completely accountable, then -- heck, just call him Fred."

If you feel you - and those you talk with - can only be accountable if you know whom you are talking to, then a forum, which discloses everyone’s identity, is the place for you.

Thanks to Mr. Ticknor, he has created such a place. He posted about it in another thread, but I didn't want it getting hidden. As I post this, there have already been 88 SIDs to register on his forum in a little under five days.

[...] I was wondering if anyone out there might be interested in joining a moderated, private (only registered users may read and write posts; users must register with a .edu or other non-anonymous e-mail address) discussion board for SIDs.

I've got no problem with this blog and understand the desire for anonymity when it comes to some hot-button issues.

The discussion board I have in mind is more about just the dry, every-day aspects of the profession (a place for shop talk if you will).

I've actually already set up the board on a free discussion board hosting site and was debating whether or not actually running with it. If I can get some interest from the readers of this blog, I'll spread the word on a larger scale. If it becomes popular, I'll be looking for some volunteer moderators as well. If it flops, it flops.

Here's the link. The terms of use/rules forum is open to be read by unregistered users.

http://sid.s10.forumsplace.com

Phil Ticknor
Sports Information Director
Washington College

Monday, August 07, 2006

SID Profession Case Studies

OK, time for a new thread before the nerd SIDs start slashing the boozing athletic communicators with their pocket protectors. So perhaps YC talk will be history, for a while anyway. It just would not be right for that thread to be the most popular in Dis-SID history...

At times we all yearn for greener pastures, but then again we are grateful for our jobs in athletics and communications. The idea for this new topic is to offer examples of certain individuals’ (whose names will be changed to protect the employed) experiences in the profession.

While the blog gets bashed for anonymity, I really think we can see how the other half lives and maybe get some clarity with this scholarly case study. So let’s offer some case studies—you or friends who have worked or are working in the field—on their quality of life, etc.

Let me present to you Ziggy Semicolon. He worked at a lower level NCAA DI institution. Zig brought stability to a shop that had seen a lot of turnover. Yet you know the drill: he was over-worked, underpaid, and needed more help that the one GA. He burnt out after a few years.

Mr. Semicolon applied for a got a job at a smaller school in the public information office. He makes about the same money, is not the head of the department, and works 9 to 5. With a young family the change seems to suit him.

It should be noted, however, that Mr. Semicolon is NOT a sports junkie. It was easier for him than for perhaps most of us to leave sports information. In summary, Ziggy seems to have made the right choice for him and family.

What about your very unscientific case studies?